Prediction Errors

When expectation does NOT meet reality

This week I came across something that stuck with me, especially In the way that It connects to our dogs.

The idea was simple: our brains like predictability. When things stay where we left them, when routines feel familiar, our nervous system can relax. But when something changes unexpectedly, even something small, our brain has to work harder. It has to reassess, update, and figure out what’s going on. That extra effort can feel like stress. These events are called prediction errors.

And it made me think… this is exactly what so many of our dogs are experiencing.

Imagine

Think about walking into your home one day and the furniture has been rearranged, the lights are different, and someone new is moving around unpredictably. You’d probably feel a little on edge, right? Maybe distracted, maybe unsettled. Now imagine that feeling happening more often than not.

For a lot of dogs, especially those who struggle with or are prone to reactivity, anxiety, or overstimulation, the world can feel like that all the time.

A leash that’s sometimes loose and sometimes tight.
A cue that sometimes gets reinforced and sometimes doesn’t.
A stranger who approaches quickly one day and ignores them the next.
A dog at the park that plays nicely… until it doesn’t.

From our perspective, these might seem like small, normal variations. But from your dog’s perspective, they can feel like constant “prediction errors”, moments where what they expected doesn’t match what actually happens.

And when those moments stack up, dogs don’t just “misbehave”… they cope.

They bark.
They lunge.
They shut down.
They get overly excited or completely avoidant.

Not because they’re being difficult, but because their brain is working overtime trying to make sense of an unpredictable world. And every dog Is so different.

What You Can Do

The unpredictability in our world is exactly why consistency in training is so powerful.

When we create clear patterns, when a cue always means the same thing, when calm behavior reliably leads to something good, when boundaries are predictable, we’re not just teaching skills. We’re giving your dog a sense of safety.

We’re reducing how much their brain has to guess.

We’re helping them feel like, “I know how this works.”

And that’s where real confidence starts to build.

So here’s something I want you to gently think about this week:

Where might your dog be experiencing unpredictability?

It could be in something small like how often you ask for a behavior but don’t follow through, or how different family members respond in different ways. It could be in something bigger like inconsistent routines, changing environments, or unclear expectations.

You don’t have to overhaul everything. Just notice.

Because even one area where you add a little more clarity and consistency can make a big difference in how your dog feels and how they show up.

Training isn’t just about teaching dogs what to do.
It’s about making their world make sense.

And when their world makes sense… everything gets easier.

—
As always, I’m here if you need help finding those areas or building a plan that feels doable for you and your dog. I encourage you all to some time this week to consider one way your dog may be experiencing prediction errors and what you can do to Improve that.